Five Bedroom Rentals | Perfect for Large Families & Groups
31 properties available
Welcome to "Lilly s Butterscotch Cottage" a beautiful 1870 Historic Victorian home that has been lovingly maintained and upgraded while still keeping its charm & integrity. This 5 bedroom, 5 bath with spacious open bonus loft family home features a formal dining room for (10), eat-in kitchen, and two living rooms so there s plenty space to just re
303 S. Broadway
Cape May
$3,600 - $8,950 / per week
5
bedrooms
5
baths
12
guests
Nestled on the edge of the Nature Conservancy land with amazing views of the meadows, lighthouse and ocean this lovely raised two story home is a Birder s delight. Home features great room with french doors to deck, 5 bedrooms, den, 3 full baths, living room, eat in kitchen, sunroom with wood burning stove, screened porch and gated in-ground pool.
324 First Avenue
West Cape May
$1,800 - $8,175 / per week
5
bedrooms
3
baths
10
guests
Pool
This serenely situated property provides all the features and amenities you could imagine plus being easily walkable to the beach, Washington Street Mall, and Cape May attractions. This is the ideal location for your family s annual vacation/reunion. There is a nice balance between congregate settings and smaller breakout areas for your guests.
915 Columbia Avenue
Cape May
$4,700 - $12,300 / per week
5
bedrooms
3
baths
1
Half baths
17
guests
Pool
Imagine this: Sun-drenched days filled with refreshing dips in your private pool. Picture cozy evenings spent with your loved ones in a stylish, newly constructed haven. This stunning 5-bedroom rental home makes dreams a reality, nestled just steps from the captivating beauty of Cape Mays tranquil beaches. Step inside and discover open-concept livi
403 Pittsburgh Ave.
Cape May
$13,000 / per week
5
bedrooms
3
baths
1
Half baths
12
guests
Pool
Adorable 5 bedroom house, 3 blocks from the beach, private back yard, central air, deck, and outside shower. Biking and walking distance to restaurants and shopping. Make this your location for your next Cape May vacation.
First Floor
Bedroom 1 - Double Bed
Bedroom 2- Twin Bed with Twin Trundle
Second Floor
Bedroom 3 - King Bed + Twin Sofa Bed
Be
1302 Maryland Avenue
Cape May
$2,250 - $4,000 / per week
5
bedrooms
2
baths
10
guests
Welcome to 2703 Bay Drive, located directly on Delaware Bay in Cape May Beach. This five-bedroom, four-bathroom bayfront estate, sleeping 12, is nestled in the dunes on a secluded lot surrounded by nature and beautiful water views. With breathtaking views, you\'ll appreciate watching the dolphins and sunsets on your private boardwalk from the house
2703 Bay Drive
Villas
$10,000 - $12,000 / per week
5
bedrooms
4
baths
12
guests
Pool
Built in 1930 the Stokes family Cape May Cottage is now known as JACK\'S PLACE. We are calling the home "Jack\'s Place" in loving memory of Jack Stokes. The Stokes Family still resides in the Cape May area and after growing up on the sandy beaches of cool Cape May - felt the home should be shared with other families to continue the tradition of joy
32 Second Avenue
Cape May
$4,850 - $7,550 / per week
5
bedrooms
2
baths
10
guests
Featured home on the Destination Channel - Staycation! A wonderful Cape May vacation on historic Jackson Street. This charming property has 5 Bedrooms, 4 Full Bathrooms, and sleeps up to 14 guests. This property was originally built by John McConnell in 1883 and has been a joy to guests ever since. When you stay at this property, you are located on
15 Jackson Street
Cape May
$11,500 - $15,000 / per week
5
bedrooms
4
baths
14
guests
Pool
Welcome to 806 Benton Avenue in the center of Cape May. This beautiful 5 bedroom home with a gorgeous kitchen, rooftop deck and private backyard.
As you walk into the home you are greeted into the living room. There is a sitting room off the living are additional entertaining. The kitchen is open to the dining area. There is a first floor master
806 Benton Avenue
Cape May
$3,595 - $6,695 / per week
5
bedrooms
4
baths
12
guests
Nestled in a beautifully landscaped setting, this five-bedroom, three-full-bath home offers the perfect retreat for your next Cape May vacation. Located on the prestigious Stevens Street in West Cape May, the home provides easy access to the best the area has to offer. Start your day with a stroll to Beach Plum Farm for breakfast, enjoy an afternoo
121 Stevens Street
West Cape May
$1,800 - $9,000 / per week
5
bedrooms
3
baths
1
Half baths
12
guests
Pool
Welcome to 486 West Perry Street, West Cape May! This 5 bedroom, 2 Bathroom home sits across from Wilbraham Park, is steps from restaurants in shops in West Cape May and Cape May and is a short walk to the beach—central location and charm in one!
BEDROOMS: FIRST FLOOR: Bedroom 1: Queen Bed, Bedroom 2: Queen Bed.
SECOND FLOOR: Bedroom 3: 2 Twin
486 West Perry Street
Cape May
$3,250 - $4,500 / per week
5
bedrooms
2
baths
10
guests
Charming five-bedroom home located on picturesque Columbia Ave and conveniently located to to town and the beach. First floor is open concept with living area, dining area and modern kitchen. There are three bedrooms located on the first floor and an updated shared bathroom with a combined tub/shower. First floor bedrooms are a king bed in rear, qu
813 Columbia Ave WHOLE HOUSE
Cape May
$4,000 - $4,900 / per week
5
bedrooms
2
baths
1
Half baths
13
guests
Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.
Copyright © 2026 • Coastline Realty
All Rights Reserved.