Coastline Realty’s Record Breaking Cape May Sales

Historical MLS Records for Record-Breaking Sales in Cape May, NJ Represented by Coastline Realty

Welcome to Coastline Realty’s archive of record-breaking real estate transactions in Cape May, New Jersey. The index below highlights historic, all-time highest sales set at the time of settlement across residential, commercial, and land properties where Coastline Realty proudly represented the buyer, seller, or both.

(Data Disclosure: Historical sales data is sourced from the Cape May County Association of REALTORS® Multiple Listing Service dating back to August 2012. The records listed below curate the specific top MLS sales held by Coastline Realty agents set at the time of settlement. Records note when they were set based on the Settlement Date of the sale. This index does not include private, off-market sales, or records not held by Coastline Realty.)

Record Sales by Property Type

• 605 Madison Avenue, Cape May
• Settlement Date: February 9, 2023
• Coastline Realty Agent: Carol Menz (Seller's Agent)
• Sale Price: $8,750,000
• Record set at Settlement: Highest ever sale price in Cape May for any type of property at time of settlement.

• 605 Madison Avenue, Cape May
• Settlement Date: February 9, 2023
• Coastline Realty Agent: Carol Menz (Seller's Agent)
• Sale Price: $8,750,000
• Record set at Settlement: Highest ever sale price in Cape May for a commercial property at time of settlement.

• 1505 Yacht Avenue, Cape May
• Settlement Date: January 15, 2026
• Coastline Realty Agent: Carol Menz (Seller's Agent and Buyer's Agent)
• Sale Price: $6,500,000
• Record set at Settlement: Highest ever sale price in Cape May for land / a lot at time of settlement.

Record Sales by Street (Alphabetical)

• 704 Benton Avenue, Cape May
• Settlement Date: March 13, 2023
• Coastline Realty Agent: Carol Menz (Seller's Agent)
• Sale Price: $2,497,000
• Record set at Settlement: Highest ever sale price on Benton Avenue at time of settlement.

Elmira Street Records

• 533 Elmira Street, Cape May
• Settlement Date: November 1, 2024
• Coastline Realty Agent: Robert Hartman Jr (Buyer's Agent)
• Sale Price: $3,515,000
• Record set at Settlement: Highest ever sale price on Elmira Street at time of settlement.

Cape May Avenue Records

• 1320 Cape May Avenue, Cape May
• Settlement Date: February 27, 2025
• Coastline Realty Agent: Ami Menz and Carol Menz (Buyer's Agent)
• Sale Price: $2,600,000
• Record set at Settlement: 4th highest ever sales price on Cape May Avenue at time of settlement.

Columbia Avenue Records

• 613 & 635 Columbia Avenue, Cape May (The Mainstay Inn)
• Settlement Date: March 25,2024
• Coastline Realty Agent: Eileen Stefan (Buyer's Agent)
• Sale Price: $2,550,000
• Record set at Settlement: Highest ever commercial and total sale price on Columbia Avenue at time of settlement.

Grant Street Records

• 225 Grant Street, Cape May
• Settlement Date: September 6, 2024
• Coastline Realty Agent: Cody Menz (Buyer's Agent)
• Sale Price: $2,400,000
• Record set at Settlement: 2nd highest sales price on Grant Street ever and the #1 highest residential sales price ever on Grant Street at time of settlement.

Harbor Cove Records

• 44 Harbor Cove, Cape May
• Settlement Date: February 12, 2026
• Coastline Realty Agent: Carol Menz (Seller's Agent)
• Sale Price: $2,850,000
• Record set at Settlement: Highest sales price ever in Cape May Harbor Village and Yacht Club and also on Harbor Cove.

• 29 Harbor Cove, Cape May
• Settlement Date: May 22, 2020
• Coastline Realty Agent: Bojidar "Bob" Dimitrov (Buyer's Agent)
• Sale Price: $2,600,000
• Record set at Settlement: 2nd Highest sales price ever on Harbor Cove at time of settlement.

Madison Avenue Records

• 605 Madison Avenue, Cape May
• Settlement Date: February 9, 2023
• Coastline Realty Agent: Carol Menz (Seller's Agent)
• Sale Price: $8,750,000
• Record set at Settlement: Highest ever sale price on Madison Avenue at time of settlement.

New Jersey Avenue Records

• 1319 New Jersey Avenue, Cape May
• Settlement Date: December 12, 2022
• Coastline Realty Agent: Anne Barry (Buyer's Agent)
• Sale Price: $3,400,000
• Record set at Settlement: Highest ever sale price on New Jersey Avenue at time of settlement

• 1120 New Jersey Avenue, Cape May
• Settlement Date: June 10, 2021
• Coastline Realty Agent: Carol Menz (Buyer's Agent)
• Sale Price: $2,650,000
• Record set at Settlement: 2nd highest ever sale price on New Jersey Avenue at time of settlement.

New York Avenue Records

• 1621 New York Avenue, Cape May
• Settlement Date: April 1, 2026
• Coastline Realty Agent: Carol Menz (Buyer's Agent)
• Sale Price: $3,500,000
• Record set at Settlement: Highest sale price ever on New York Avenue at time of settlement.

• 1009 New York Avenue, Cape May
• Settlement Date: May 8, 2022
• Coastline Realty Agent: Carol Menz (Buyer's Agent)
• Sale Price: $3,200,000
• Record set at Settlement: Highest sale price ever on New York Avenue at time of settlement.

Ocean Street Records

• 24 Ocean Street, Cape May
• Settlement Date: January 26, 2022
• Coastline Realty Agent: Kimberly Gipple (Seller's Agent)
• Sale Price: $2,537,579
• Record set at Settlement: 2nd highest sale price ever on Ocean Street for residential properties at time of settlement.

Pittsburgh Avenue Records

• 401 Pittsburgh Avenue, Cape May
• Settlement Date: December 3, 2024
• Coastline Realty Agent: Holli Cappelli (Buyer's Agent)
• Sale Price: $2,599,000
• Record set at Settlement: 2nd highest sales price ever on Pittsburgh Avenue at time of settlement.

Queen Street Records

• 15 Queen Street, Cape May
• Settlement Date: October 25, 2019
• Coastline Realty Agent: Ami Menz and Carol Menz (Buyer's Agent)
• Sale Price: $2,650,000
• Record set at Settlement: Highest sales price ever on Queen Street at time of settlement.

Stockton Avenue Records

• 1003 Stockton Avenue, Cape May
• Settlement Date: January 6, 2021
• Coastline Realty Agent: Carol Menz (Seller's Agent and Buyer's Agent)
• Sale Price: $3,600,000
• Record set at Settlement: Highest sales price ever on Stockton Avenue at time of settlement.

• 1003 Stockton Avenue, Cape May
• Settlement Date: September 21, 2018
• Coastline Realty Agent: Carol Menz (Seller's Agent and Buyer's Agent)
• Sale Price: $3,160,000
• Record set at Settlement: Highest sales price ever on Stockton Avenue at time of settlement.

Washington Street Records

• 1109 Washington Street, Cape May
• Settlement Date: July 10, 2024
• Coastline Realty Agent: Ami Menz & Cody Menz (Seller's Agent) and Carol Menz & Tai Menz (Buyer's Agent)
• Sale Price: $2,949,000
• Record set at Settlement: 3rd highest ever sale price on Washington Street and the #1 highest ever sale price for a residential property on Washington Street at time of settlement.

Yacht Avenue Records

• 1505 Yacht Avenue, Cape May
• Settlement Date: January 15, 2026
• Coastline Realty Agent: Carol Menz (Seller's Agent and Buyer's Agent)
• Sale Price: $6,500,000
• Record set at Settlement: Highest ever sale price on Yacht Avenue at time of settlement.

Record Sales by Association (Alphabetical)

Cape May Harbor Village and Yacht Club

• 44 Harbor Cove, Cape May
• Settlement Date: February 12, 2026
• Coastline Realty Agent: Carol Menz (Seller's Agent)
• Sale Price: $2,850,000
• Record set at Settlement: Highest sales price ever in Cape May Harbor Village and Yacht Club and also on Harbor Cove at time of settlement.